Senator Michael Testa has voiced opposition to reports that Governor Phil Murphy is preparing to issue an executive order permitting individuals convicted of serious crimes to serve on juries. This move comes after the New Jersey Legislature rejected a similar proposal in 2023.
“Once again, Governor Murphy is attempting to impose his personal agenda by executive fiat after the people’s representatives clearly said no,” said Senator Testa. “This proposal was debated and rejected by the Legislature, yet the Governor now appears determined to circumvent that decision in the final days of his administration.”
Testa stated that he does not believe the governor has legal authority to change jury eligibility standards, which are part of longstanding state law. “Clemency exists to lessen punishment imposed on an individual,” Testa said. “The exclusion of convicted criminals from jury service is not a punishment at all – it is a policy judgment designed to protect the integrity, impartiality, and public credibility of the judicial system. Any impact on offenders is incidental to that goal, not punitive in nature, and therefore well outside the constitutional scope of the Governor’s clemency power.”
Testa emphasized the importance of separation of powers within state government. “The separation of powers matters,” Testa said. “The Governor does not get to override the Legislature simply because he disagrees with its judgment. If this reckless policy could not pass through the democratic process, it should not be imposed by executive decree.”
He further commented on what he views as the responsibilities attached to jury service: “Individuals convicted of serious crimes broke the social contract that binds our society together,” Testa continued. “Serving on a jury is not a right, privilege, or entitlement. Rather, it is a profound civic duty – and one that is not to be conferred lightly. The solemn power to sit in judgment of others under the law should not be entrusted to those who have shown a willingness to violate it.”
Testa also criticized Governor Murphy’s approach as his term nears its end: “Even as his tenure comes to an end, Governor Murphy continues to side with criminals over law-abiding citizens,” Testa said. “New Jersey families deserve a justice system that puts public safety, accountability, and respect for the law first – not one that elevates the rights of convicted felons above those of victims and everyday citizens.”
He called on Governor Murphy to drop this proposal and honor both legislative intent and public opinion.
State Senator Anthony M. Bucco serves as Senate Republican Leader and chairs the Senate Judiciary Committee while representing New Jersey’s 25th Legislative District official website. He participates in legislative work including sponsoring bills and contributing to committee discussions on key state issues official website. Bucco provides constituent services through his district office for communities such as Bernardsville Borough, Boonton Town and Denville Township.
